Skip to main content

Does Gandhi's civil resistance always work?

Gandhi's salt march
Non-violent civil resistance is a wonderful idea whose utility cannot be underestimated.  In theory and practice, the authority which does not lead by consent will naturally lose its foundation.  If the non-violent civil resisters are brutalised, then the authority loses all vestiges of legitimacy since legitimacy stems from honorable action and popular consent.
However, it is not a principle that can work universally.  Non-violent civil resistance worked well in India for a number of reasons.
The first is the population in India outnumbered the British expatriate class and administration by over a thousand to one.  Secondly, the vast geographical expanse between India and England was a further deterrent to keeping India.  Keeping India could only be justified (from an economic perspective) if the risks and losses from such a distance could be mitigated or exceeded by the resources gained from ruling.  Furthermore, the administration was already stretched thinly over the vast expanse of India itself.
Thirdly, while the British viewed themselves as superior, they still did not view the Indians as being on the same level as Africans.  They acknowledged that they lived in a land with an ancient and sophisticated history.  This is important, in that violent action against the non-violent Indians would result in a greater degree of guilt, than if they viewed the Indians as lower than dogs.
The same principles that Gandhi advocated would not have worked for the Jews in Nazi Germany, given that the Jews were already viewed as a population that needed to be purged for the sake of ‘racial hygiene’.  In other words, the Jews were viewed as lower than dogs.  This is why the regime showed no compunction in exterminating the Jewish population. 
The principles would not really have worked for Ireland in times before the 20th century.  The British mainland was only a few tens of miles away at its shortest point to Ireland.  The same logistical trouble with India would not be experienced with Ireland.  Furthermore, the small Irish population in comparison to that of Britain, allowed the British to conduct large population transfers of Irish people to foreign colonies.  The Irish evicted from their homes were easily replaced by British settlers.  Hence the successful Ulster plantation. 
Furthermore, the most successful civil resistance movements are galvanised by the propagation of narrative.  Accounts of the Amritsar massacre in India were circulated widely in India and in Britain.  Martin Luther King’s messages and meetings were broadcasted all around the world. 
When there is not a healthy media presence, a civil resistance movement can be squashed easily.  When an event receives massive publicity, it is harder for an administration to ‘sin quietly’ as the British often did in Kenya.  Civil resistance will eventually descend into violence when peaceful action is deemed to be fruitless.
Another problem that civil resistance faces is when they operate in a country which is subject to frequent acts of violence from other groups.  This can allow a corrupt administration to justify repression against all dissent, labeling them all as terrorists, traitors, agitators, etc.
In summary, non-violent civil resistance can only be sure to work where a very large population is impossible to control, transfer, or be goaded into violence and where the oppression can be observed and judged by all.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Whatever happened to slingers?

Andean sling - Img source Wikimedia commons This is a question that crops up in forums and discussions about ancient combat.  Slingers were described by the ancients in very positive terms.  Suddenly they were no longer present.  There are scanty records of sling combat post-antiquity and many explanations have been postulated for their demise. The first is that slings were replaced by bows.   Bows became predominant simply because they were better, more precise, farther reaching etc. The problem with this theory is that while both slings and bows are biodegradable, the oldest discovered bows (Holmegaarde, 6000 BC) predate the oldest sling discovered (2500 BC, Lovelock cave) by thousands of years.   The theory also discounts all written evidence concerning the sling.   Slings were crude but powerful weapons which could project missiles much further than an archer could shoot an arrow.   Long range throwing also depended on the type of ammun...

Why did the Romans use swords instead of spears? (A reply to Metatron)

Relief depicting Persian spearmen Metatron, for those who don’t know of him, has made many excellent videos on YouTube regarding historical events and peoples.  He specialises in Japanese and Ancient Roman history, but regularly answers questions on other historical periods. In one of his videos, he gives his view of why the Romans used swords instead of spears, as most warriors and soldiers did in antiquity. He proposed that the Romans chose swords instead of spears because of the equipment of the opponents that they fought.  Most of them, he said were barbarians rather than the armoured men of later eras.  He rightly stated that the Romans would have quickly adapted their army to an armoured threat if they had to face one.  He gave an example of the Roman legions quickly employing the manica (arm guard) in response to the Dacian falx. While he makes a good point about Roman adaptation to the threats they faced, the hypothesis that the Roman soldiers fa...

The decline of the use of shields in warfare

For the majority of the history of warfare, the shield has featured prominently.  It was mostly used by infantry and then by archers and cavalry.  It had great utility in deflecting blows and protecting the user from missiles.             With such great utility, how did it decline in usage? Some might say that gunpowder small arms had something to do with it.  The fact is that shields were increasingly discarded by close combat troops prior to the widespread adoption of firearms. A shield was typically made from wooden slats (or wicker in some Middle Eastern constructions) and covered with rawhide for extra reinforcement and protection. Some early depictions of the shield in massed combat were Assyrian reliefs showing spearmen with large tower shields protecting archers and slingers.   Assyrian soldiers The Persian Sparabara functioned in the same way.  The use of the shield was never ...